The Prince of Pittsburgh's Perfect Pizza Quest
The Prince of Pittsburgh's Perfect Pizza Quest
Embedded Files
The Prince of Pittsburgh has made his decision on the pizza offered by these establishments. Six attributes were evaluated on a 1-10 scale for a possible perfect score of 60.
Bellaria - Kent, OH
135 East Erie Street
Suite 202
Kent, OH 44240
330-678-6000
www.bellariakent.com
July 23, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
7 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
9 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
9 - General Flavor
48 - Total Score
Pizza is good when you get it and also on the second day (if it lasts that long!). They have an All-you-can-eat pizza buffet six days a week for only $10. They have several locations in the Youngstown-Warren area.
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
9 - Appearance
8 - Cheese
9 - Sauce
9 - Crust
10 - Topping Amount
8 - General Flavor
53 - Total Score
This is my highest score to date. It's a bit more expensive, but worth it. I highly recommend the pizza, the calzone was very good, I'd pass on the wings.
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
7 - Cheese
9 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
42 - Total Score
While there, pick up some jars of sauce to go. Tremendous! It's the Princess' go to sauce for pasta.
667 Castle Creek Dr.
Seven Fields, PA 16046
724-778-9955
www.carluccissevenfields.com
February 7, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
6 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
39 - Total Score
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
6 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
39 - Total Score
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
5 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
35 - Total Score
"I liked it better many years ago; maybe they had an off day. On this day it was a mediocre pie. However, if you're going there for the "scenery", a middle-of-the-road pizza will not affect your experience"
Domenico's Restaurante
20550 Route 19 (Piazza Plaza)
Cranberry Tw, PA 16066
724-776-6455
www.domenicoscranberry.com
June 15, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
5 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
35 - Total Score
The pizza was average, but the extras (wings, JoJos, etc.) were excellent
4251 Northern Pike
Monroeville, PA 15146
412-372-2977
gatewaygrill35@yahoo.com
February 28, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
6 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
6 - Sauce
4 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
34 - Total Score
Sometimes it just depends when the pizza gets taken out of the oven. In this case, had it been removed 90 seconds earlier, the crust , appearance, and general flavor would have received higher scores
Ohio
3975 Cascades Blvd.
Kent, OH 44240
234-233-1494
November 18, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
5 - Sauce
6 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
5 - General Flavor
35 - Total Score
The pizza was average, but the extras (wings, JoJos, etc.) were excellent
161 Scharberry Ln.
Mar, PA 16046
724-687-0480
lucianositalianbrickoven.com
Open 11am-10 pm Wed-Sun
Closed Monday and Tuesday
November 13, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
5 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
40 - Total Score
The best in the Mars area
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
7 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
5 - Crust
8 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
43 - Total Score
It was quite good, with some pizzas you could not select a size. Mac and cheese bites were great.
Monte Cello's Cranberry
20325 Route 19
Cranberry Township, PA 16066
724-772-3133
montecellos.com/cranberry
Open 11am-9 pm Tues-Thurs,
11 am-10 pm Fri and Sat
Closed Sunday and Monday
October 18, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
5 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
40 - Total Score
Nice atmosphere, popular place. Getting a table in the bar area is much more fun than the dining room. The pizza was average, but the beer was cold!
NPL Bamboo Bar
20810 Route 19
Cranberry Twp, PA 16066
724-772-2233
www.northparkloungecranberry.com
August 8, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
6 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
7 - Sauce
5 - Crust
5 - Topping Amount
8 - General Flavor
37 - Total Score
"They add a spice that gives us a good flavor, but besides that, it's definitely bar pizza. But it's such a fun place, who cares? The chicken tenders are excellent."
2016 Smallman St.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-429-7272
www.papajs.com
January 12, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pizza tray:
7 - Appearance
6 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
7 - Crust
8 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
43 - Total Score
It was very good, slightly pricey, but Papa J's is a full-blown Italian restaurant as opposed to a pizza joint. Try their zucchini!
Pine Township, PA
11085 Babcock Blvd
Gibsonia PA 15044
724-65-2600
November 11, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
5 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
5 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
6 - General Flavor
39 - Total Score
This has been my go-to Pizza Place for years. I think they had a bad day or perhaps I've been overrating them.
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
7 - Cheese
7 - Sauce
9 - Crust
7 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
45 - Total Score
I’ve liked this place for years, located adjacent to the Oakmont Country Club. Nice environment, friendly service, reasonable prices.
Steel Mill Saloon - Mt. Washington
1225 Grandview Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15211
412-586-4926
www.steelmillsaloon.com
July 3, 2025
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
7 - Appearance
5 - Cheese
8 - Sauce
9 - Crust
6 - Topping Amount
6 - General Flavor
41 - Total Score
Located right across the street from the Duquesne Incline, this venue has a nice atmosphere and the pizza is unique. Best of all, between 3:30 and 6:00, the pizzas are half price!
Supremo's Pizzeria
631 PA-228
Mars, PA 16046
724-625-1700
November 18, 2024
The Prince evaluated a pepperoni pie:
8 - Appearance
7 - Cheese
7 - Sauce
6 - Crust
8 - Topping Amount
7 - General Flavor
43 - Total Score
Very good and cheaper than most.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse